top of page
new hoga logo icon upscaled.jpg

Federal Court orders IRCC to make a decision after 5-year Start-up Visa wait

Writer: Nicholas Wu
Nicholas Wu
13 hours ago
8 min read

In Naghavi v. Canada, 2026 FC 1370, the Federal Court gave IRCC 90 days to decide a Start-up Visa application that had been pending for 67 months. For roughly 29 of those months, IRCC’s own records showed the file was ready for a decision. Justice Michael Battista found that changes to processing priorities did not adequately explain why the applicant still had no realistic end date. IRCC retained responsibility for deciding whether to grant permanent residence. Naghavi, paras. 3, 20–22, 32–36 and final order.


For applicants who filed before 30 April 2024, when the first priority rules took effect, this is encouraging. There is also reason for caution. Less than three months before Naghavi, another Federal Court judge considered a Start-up Visa applicant’s request for the same remedy, known as mandamus, and declined to order a decision. That earlier case, Jin v. Canada, applied the same legal framework. The outcome can depend on the evidence in your file and on whether the judge hearing your case finds IRCC’s explanation persuasive. Read Jin v. Canada, 2026 FC 1080.


How a decision-ready file kept moving back

Mr. Naghavi applied in March 2021, with support from Biomedical Commercialization Canada Inc., operating as Manitoba Technology Accelerator. Just over three years later, in June 2024, an officer recorded that he met the program requirements, was admissible and that his file was ready for finalization. He was still waiting when the Court heard his case in November 2026. The parties agreed on the reason: two successive sets of Ministerial Instructions had moved other applicants ahead of him. No one suggested that he or his lawyer had caused the delay. Naghavi, paras. 3–6, 12 and 16.


The first change came shortly before the officer marked his file ready. On 30 April 2024, new instructions gave priority to applications backed by certain commitments from designated organisations. The rules expressly covered applications already in the queue. Mr. Naghavi had filed in 2021, but a later applicant with qualifying support could still go ahead of him.

The December 2025 instructions kept those same commitments and added a work permit condition. From 1 January 2026, first priority went to teams with a qualifying commitment and at least one member holding a valid SUV-specific work permit. Teams with qualifying support alone came second. All other applications came third. By then, Mr. Naghavi’s file had been ready for about 18 months. December 2025 Ministerial Instructions.


IRCC later identified A77 as the qualifying permit code in guidance issued on 10 November 2026. IRCC guidance.


Why IRCC’s estimate failed to explain the wait

In September 2026, IRCC gave Mr. Naghavi an estimate of another 31 months. That number might have given him something to plan around, except for one fact: IRCC’s evidence acknowledged that the estimate left out the effect of the December 2025 instructions. An unknown number of applicants would go ahead of him. Even if he waited the full two and a half years, the estimate gave him little basis to expect a decision by then. Naghavi, paras. 24 and 32–33.


Justice Battista accepted that the Minister has authority to set priorities and that those priorities can justify delay. His concern was what that explanation meant for this file. An officer had finished the substantive assessment more than two years earlier. The file had fallen behind two priority groups. If each new set of instructions could justify a further wait without a realistic estimate, what would prevent the delay from continuing indefinitely? On that record, he granted mandamus. Naghavi, paras. 25–38 and 42–43.


Why another Start-up Visa applicant got a different result

On 21 August 2026, Justice Negar Azmudeh dismissed the mandamus application in Jin v. Canada. Mr. Jin had applied in February 2022 and passed eligibility in January 2024. His own security screening, however, remained outstanding. There was also a separate obstacle: in December 2025, the designated organisation supporting his application had been suspended, putting processing on hold. Read the Jin judgment.


Both judges had to consider whether the wait exceeded what the process required, whether the applicant contributed to it and whether IRCC had a satisfactory explanation. In Jin, Justice Azmudeh accepted that the Minister could lawfully place other applications first. She did not find that the lower priority amounted to an indefinite delay. The organisation’s suspension also affected whether IRCC had a duty to continue processing the application at that time.


Justice Battista addressed Jin directly. He distinguished it because that decision focused on the validity of the instructions and did not rest on a finding of open-ended delay. In Mr. Naghavi’s case, the Minister’s authority was never seriously in dispute. The difficulty was explaining how a file that IRCC itself considered ready could remain pending for years with no credible estimate of completion. Naghavi therefore leaves Jin in place. Naghavi, paras. 37 and 41–43.


What this means for your application

Which judge hears your case can matter. In Jin, the judge accepted IRCC’s explanation for the delay. In Naghavi, the judge found that the estimate failed to account for the repeated delays on a file already marked ready for a decision. Both the evidence and how the judge assesses it can affect the outcome.


If you are considering your next step, start with two dates: when you applied, and when an officer last recorded what remained to be done. Obtain current GCMS notes, check for outstanding requests or assessments, and keep dated records of your business activity and your role. An eligibility finding, a completed security assessment and an express note that a file is ready for finalization each tell you something different about the wait.


If your file has been ready for a prolonged period and IRCC has given you no realistic timeframe, an immigration litigation lawyer can review the record with you and explain the prospects, costs and risks of seeking a court order.


This article provides general information and does not constitute legal or immigration advice. Before deciding what to do about your application, seek advice from a licensed immigration professional who can review your circumstances. If you are considering mandamus, consult a lawyer who handles Federal Court immigration proceedings.

繁體中文版|Start-up Visa 申請等了五年,聯邦法院下令 IRCC 限期作出決定

在 Naghavi v. Canada, 2026 FC 1370 一案中,一名 Start-up Visa (SUV) 申請人等了 67 個月,聯邦法院最終下令,要求加拿大移民部(IRCC)在 90 天內就其申請作出決定。這 67 個月裡,約有 29 個月,連 IRCC 自己的紀錄也顯示,個案已可作最終決定。Michael Battista 法官認為,雖然審理次序有變,但這不足以解釋為甚麼申請人至今連一個可信的完成時間也得不到。法院訂下的是決定期限,最終是否批准永久居留,仍由 IRCC 決定。 判詞第 3、20 至 22、32 至 36 段及最終命令


對於在首輪優先審理規則生效前,即 2024 年 4 月 30 日之前遞交申請的人來說,這宗判決值得鼓舞,但也要留意另一宗案件。就在 Naghavi 判決前不足三個月,另一位聯邦法院法官在 Jin v. Canada 一案中,按同一套法律準則審理另一名 SUV 申請人的強制令(mandamus)申請,卻拒絕下令要求 IRCC 限期作出決定。你的個案有甚麼證據,以及主審法官是否認為 IRCC 的解釋有說服力,都會影響結果。 Jin v. Canada, 2026 FC 1080


Naghavi 的申請已可作決定,為甚麼仍要等?

Naghavi 於 2021 年 3 月遞交申請,獲以 Manitoba Technology Accelerator 名義營運的 Biomedical Commercialization Canada Inc. 支持。三年多後,即 2024 年 6 月,審理人員記錄在案:Naghavi 符合計劃要求,已通過准入審查,個案可以作最終決定。但到了 2026 年 11 月聆訊時,他已再等了約 29 個月,前後合共約 67 個月。雙方都同意,兩輪部長指令先後令其他申請人的審理次序排在他之前。也沒有人指延誤是由 Naghavi 或其律師造成。 判詞第 3 至 6、12、16 及 20 至 22 段


第一輪改動,在審理人員註明個案已可作決定前不久生效。自 2024 年 4 月 30 日起,獲指定機構提供以下任何一項合資格支持的申請,可獲優先審理。指令明文涵蓋已在輪候的申請。因此,即使 Naghavi 早在 2021 年已遞交申請,較遲遞交的人只要符合條件,仍可排在他之前。

2025 年 12 月的部長指令保留上述條件,並加入工作許可證要求。由 2026 年 1 月 1 日起,團隊獲合資格支持,而且至少一名成員持有有效的 SUV 專屬工作許可證,其申請可獲第一優先。只符合支持條件的團隊排第二,其餘申請排第三。到新次序生效時,Naghavi 的個案已可作最終決定約 18 個月。 《加拿大憲報》2025 年 12 月部長指令


其後,IRCC 在 2026 年 11 月 10 日發出的指引中,列明合資格的工作許可證代碼為 A77。 IRCC 指引


IRCC 給了預計時間,法官為甚麼仍不接受?

2026 年 9 月,IRCC 告知 Naghavi,預計他還要再等 31 個月。有了這個數字,他原本至少可以作些打算。問題是,IRCC 在庭上提交的證據承認,這個估算沒有計入 2025 年 12 月指令的影響。究竟還有多少申請會排到他前面,沒有人說得準。即使再等足兩年半,他也沒有多少根據相信屆時會收到決定。 判詞第 24、32 至 33 段


Michael Battista 法官接受部長有權訂定審理次序,也接受優先安排可以構成延誤的合理解釋。他關注的是,這個解釋能否說明 Naghavi 這宗申請為甚麼仍要等。審理人員早在兩年多前已完成實質審查,其後卻有兩組申請排在他前面。如果每一輪新指令都足以解釋下一輪等候,而 IRCC 始終無法提出可信的完成時間,那麼這宗申請豈不是可以一直等下去?根據本案的證據,法官批准了強制令申請。 判詞第 25 至 38、42 至 43 段


同樣是 SUV 申請人,為甚麼 Jin 得到不同結果?

2026 年 8 月 21 日,Negar Azmudeh 法官在 Jin v. Canada 一案中駁回強制令申請。Jin 於 2022 年 2 月遞交 SUV 申請,並於 2024 年 1 月通過資格審查,但他本人的保安審查仍未完成。此外,支持其申請的指定機構於 2025 年 12 月被暫停資格,令個案審理也隨之暫停。這是優先次序以外的另一項障礙。 Jin v. Canada 判詞


兩位法官都要考慮三個問題:等候時間是否已超出審理程序合理所需?申請人有否造成延誤?IRCC 能否提出令人信服的解釋?在 Jin 一案中,Negar Azmudeh 法官接受部長可以依法優先處理其他申請。按該案的證據,她並不認為審理次序較後就等於要無了期等候。指定機構被暫停資格,也影響 IRCC 當時是否仍有責任繼續審理。


Michael Battista 法官在 Naghavi 判詞第 41 段直接回應了 Jin。他指出,Jin 的焦點在於部長指令是否有效,該案亦沒有認定延誤已變得無了期。至於 Naghavi,雙方對部長的權力其實沒有重大爭議。真正的問題是,IRCC 自己也認為個案已可作決定,卻讓申請人再等了數年,仍無法提出可信的完成時間。兩案有此分別,Naghavi 並沒有推翻 Jin。 判詞第 37、41 至 43 段


這對你的申請有甚麼啟示?

由哪位法官審理,確實可能影響結果。在 Jin 一案中,法官接受 IRCC 對延誤的解釋。在 Naghavi 一案中,法官則認為,IRCC 的估算未能反映一宗早已可作決定的申請一再被押後的實況。因此,即使你等候的時間與 Naghavi 相若,仍要看你的個案紀錄反映了甚麼,以及主審法官如何評估這些證據。


如果你正在考慮下一步,可以先找出兩個日期:你何時遞交申請,以及審理人員最近一次記錄個案進度是在何時、當時還有哪些程序未完成。你可以索取最新的 GCMS 個案紀錄,核對有沒有尚待回覆的補件要求或尚未完成的審查,同時保留註明日期的業務紀錄,記下你本人參與了哪些工作。「已通過資格審查」、「已完成保安審查」和「已可作最終決定」代表三種不同的進度。要了解自己為甚麼仍在等,這個分別很重要。


如果紀錄顯示你的個案早已可作決定,而 IRCC 一直未能提供可信的時間表,你可以請處理移民訴訟的律師審閱個案,向你說明申請強制令的成功機會、費用和風險,再決定是否採取法律行動。


本文僅供一般參考,不構成法律或移民意見。在決定如何處理你的申請前,請向持牌移民專業人士尋求切合你個人情況的意見。如正考慮申請強制令,請諮詢具聯邦法院移民訴訟經驗的律師。

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page